Kalshi Stock Trading Plan Surfaces as Judge Says CFTC Likely Overstepped on Stock Perps

November 17, 2026:

Kalshi Stock Trading Plan Surfaces as Judge Says CFTC Likely Overstepped on Stock Perps

Kalshi, the prediction-market exchange, bought New York broker-dealer FB Securities in July and plans to open stock and ETF trading within about two months, the Wall Street Journal reported Monday, Nov. 16. The report lands about two weeks after a federal judge said Kalshi’s new stock-linked perpetual futures likely belong under the SEC, not the CFTC that cleared them.

Which regulator governs a trade decides which rules protect the customer. Stock trading through a broker-dealer falls under SEC and FINRA rules, including customer protections, while Kalshi’s stock perps are cash-settled contracts that trade under a joint CFTC-and-SEC framework that a court has now questioned. The litigation is pending, the judge’s view is preliminary, and the CFTC and Kalshi dispute the plaintiffs’ reading of the law.

Kalshi Bought FB Securities in July, but Price, Size and Approvals Remain Unreported

CBS News reported, citing a person familiar with the matter, that Kalshi plans to let customers trade stocks and ETFs and that FB Securities will facilitate that trading. Reports on timing differ: the Journal’s sources point to a launch within about two months, CBS News described a rollout later this year, and CNBC’s source said within the next few months.

The deal’s financial terms have not been disclosed, and neither have FB Securities’ size, customer base, FINRA standing or the approvals needed to carry retail accounts under Kalshi’s ownership.

Kalshi’s last confirmed funding round, a $1 billion Series G round at a $40 billion valuation, was co-led by Wellington Management and Sequoia Capital, with Andreessen Horowitz, Coatue and Morgan Stanley participating. It was announced Oct. 29.

Judge Caproni Said Stock Perps Appear to Be Swaps Under SEC Jurisdiction

On Nov. 3, CFTC Chairman Michael Selig announced that perpetual futures on individual stocks could begin trading on CFTC-registered exchanges, after the contracts were deemed approved under CFTC Regulation 40.3 as security futures products under the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000. Selig framed the move as bringing perpetual derivatives onshore with safeguards, building on the agency’s earlier approval of Kalshi’s bitcoin perpetual.

The Capital Markets Alliance, whose members include Cboe, Citadel Securities and the Healthy Markets Association, sued the CFTC and Selig. The group argues that perpetual contracts with no fixed expiration are security-based swaps under SEC jurisdiction. Its suit alleges the CFTC failed to explain its approvals or adequately assess investor risks, claims the agency has not conceded.

U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni agreed with the group on the law at this early stage. A security future is a contract for future delivery of a stock, she reasoned, and a perpetual never delivers, so it cannot qualify. She called the CFTC’s action “a major disruption to the equities market.” She still denied an emergency halt because the harm was not shown to be actual and imminent, so Kalshi, Coinbase Derivatives and Bitnomial kept trading. Her merits finding is preliminary and not binding, and the case moved to Judge Lorna Schofield on an expedited schedule for the group’s preliminary injunction request. No ruling on that request had been reported as of Monday evening, Nov. 16.

The CFTC has defenders. On Nov. 9, Coinbase, Kalshi and Kraken parent Payward, joined by DRW Holdings, Jump Trading and Paradigm, asked the court for leave to file a brief supporting the agency. They argue that a fixed expiration date is not required for a security future and that such contracts fall under joint CFTC and SEC oversight. Wall Street’s trade group SIFMA asked the SEC and CFTC to study the market effects, decide how the contracts should be classified, and pause the filings or require refiling so the public can comment before launch. Cboe and CME Group sent similar letters in October.

Can Kalshi Customers Buy Real Shares Yet?

Not through the perps. Kalshi’s help center says a stock perp is a contract that tracks the stock’s price, so the trader owns no shares, and one report says holders receive no voting rights or shareholder materials. Kalshi’s Nov. 4 CFTC filing covers 54 cash-settled contracts, each on one security: 51 common stocks, one ADR (Alibaba) and two ETFs, SPY and QQQ, with listing set to begin Nov. 5.

Each contract has no expiration. Instead, a once-daily funding payment keeps its price near the stock’s: a positive rate means long holders pay short holders, a negative rate means the reverse, and the rate comes from the average minute-by-minute gap between the contract price and the underlying price, transferred at 4:00 p.m. ET. Trading runs from Sunday 6:00 p.m. ET through Friday 5:00 p.m. ET with a daily maintenance window, and Kalshi’s help center warns that a position can move against a trader while the market is closed.

The filing sets minimum customer margin at 15.50% of a position’s market value, cleared through Kalshi’s own clearinghouse, Kalshi Klear. Kalshi’s first four contracts, on Qualcomm, McDonald’s, Amgen and Costco, launched at up to 4.9x leverage and traded roughly $23 million shortly after launch, according to Ledger Insights. At 4.9x, a roughly 20% adverse move would equal the margin posted, by simple arithmetic and before fees and funding payments.

One rule in the same filing links the perps to broker-dealers. Customer orders may be executed only by exchange members that are futures commission merchants or introducing brokers and are also registered, or notice-registered, with the SEC as broker-dealers. No report has said whether FB Securities will fill that role.

Broker-Dealer Ownership Puts Kalshi Stock Trades Inside SEC and FINRA Jurisdiction

A broker-dealer trades securities for its own account or for customers. The SEC regulates it under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, FINRA holds delegated authority, and registered firms generally must belong to the Securities Investor Protection Corporation and seek best execution for customers.

Two things are unreported. It is unclear whether Kalshi will route equity order flow directly through FB Securities or use the license mainly to support its existing products. And no report ties the July purchase to the perps case, which came months later. One reasonable reading is that Kalshi now has two legal routes to stock exposure: perps under a CFTC and SEC security-futures framework a judge doubts, and real shares through an SEC-regulated broker.

Robinhood Fell About 7.6% While Schwab Held Near Flat After WSJ Report

Robinhood shares fell about 7.6% Monday after the Journal report, while Charles Schwab was roughly flat, according to Yahoo Finance’s market coverage. Robinhood has been both Kalshi’s biggest distributor and a rival. It has been offering Kalshi contracts since March 2025 and has driven more than half of Kalshi’s volume.

In January 2026, Robinhood and Susquehanna International Group bought 90% of MIAXdx, and Robinhood said it would keep offering Kalshi contracts alongside its own exchange’s products. Kalshi’s stock plan adds a second front, retail equities, where Schwab is also moving with Cboe S&P 500 binary options for its retail accounts.

Ninth Circuit Loss and Utah Criminal Charges Still Weigh on Kalshi’s Sports Contracts

On Aug. 28, a unanimous Ninth Circuit panel ruled that Kalshi’s sports contracts are sports bets, not federally regulated swaps, at the preliminary-injunction stage, letting Nevada enforce its gaming laws. The decision conflicts with the Third Circuit’s April 2-1 ruling for Kalshi in New Jersey. On Nov. 4, the Second Circuit denied Kalshi and Coinbase injunctions pending appeal, leaving New York and Connecticut free to enforce their gambling laws against the sports contracts.

On Oct. 28, Utah charged Kalshi, CEO Tarek Mansour and COO Luana Lopes Lara with 14 criminal counts tied to gambling promotion and unlawful activity. Kalshi called the charges “crazy overreach” and says prediction markets fall under exclusive federal jurisdiction. The charges are allegations, and no court has ruled on them.

Estimates of how much of Kalshi’s volume comes from sports vary by tracker and definition. One Dune-based count puts the sports category alone near 53% of weekly volume, while sports plus exotic contracts runs about 85% and another tracker says roughly 87%. That concentration is why diversification into stocks matters to the company.

CFTC Chair Selig Came From SEC Crypto Task Force; Kalshi Founders Came From MIT

Selig, confirmed 53-43 by the Senate in December 2025, previously served as chief counsel of the SEC’s Crypto Task Force and senior advisor to SEC Chairman Paul Atkins. His Nov. 3 statement says the equity perps rest on the 2000 law and a CFTC-SEC memorandum of understanding, but it does not describe specific retail protections.

Mansour interned at Goldman Sachs and graduated from MIT in 2018, and Lopes Lara holds an MIT master’s degree in computer science. Their public policy activity has centered on market structure: Senate Banking Committee Republicans met privately with Mansour on Sept. 23, and every Democrat on the committee urged Chairman Tim Scott to hold a public hearing the same day.

Four Unknowns Remain: Launch Date, Approvals, Fees and FB Securities’ Role in Perps

Launch timing is contested, since the Journal’s sources say about two months, CBS News’s source says later this year and CNBC’s source says within months. Required approvals for retail accounts are not described. Pricing is unknown, so it is unclear whether Kalshi will undercut zero-commission brokers. And FB Securities’ role in the perps, including the dual-registration rule above, has not been reported.

For a customer, the practical stake is which rulebook covers which product. Today Kalshi sells stock exposure as cash-settled contracts with margin and funding payments, not shares. The planned brokerage would add SEC and FINRA-regulated trading in actual stocks and ETFs, while a federal judge’s early view suggests courts may decide whether the perps belong under the CFTC or the SEC. Before funding an account, check which Kalshi entity holds it and which regulator’s protections apply.


Frequently Asked Questions

Will Kalshi let me buy actual shares of stock?

Reports say Kalshi plans to offer stocks and ETFs through FB Securities, but no launch date or product details have been confirmed by Kalshi. Until then, its stock products are perpetual contracts that track prices without share ownership.

What is the difference between a stock perp and a security future?

A traditional security future is a contract for future delivery of a stock, and Judge Caproni reasoned that a contract that never delivers cannot qualify. The CFTC and Kalshi’s allies argue that no fixed expiration is required and that such contracts fall under joint CFTC and SEC oversight.

Why does it matter whether the SEC or the CFTC oversees stock perps?

The answer determines which agency writes and enforces the rules, and whether the contracts are treated as swaps under SEC jurisdiction or security futures under joint oversight. The ruling Judge Caproni made is preliminary, so Kalshi’s perps continue to trade while the injunction request proceeds.

Could the lawsuit end Kalshi’s stock perps?

It could, but no ruling on the preliminary injunction request had been reported as of Nov. 16. If the court vacated the approvals, other exchanges whose perps were approved, including Coinbase Derivatives and Bitnomial, would also be affected.

Source link